Friday, May 20, 2011

How to pray?

Part of my editorial on the prayer issue at City Hall. And here's the top of the story I wrote about the issue, which I find fascinating and to be a good discussion about a core debate - the role of religion in government.

I've found it interesting, and pleasant, that a fair number of online comments support Tamara Nile's efforts to have a more universal prayer and her concerns that the city not give the impression that it favors one religion over another.

I expected more outrage at her concern that Jesus' name not be invoked in the prayer. That part was kind of buried in her proposal, and hasn't been sensationalized.

I think that, in the end, the prayer before the commission meeting starts is less important that the spiritual place of individual commissioners. The problem with it is that even those most folks would call themselves Christian, others would not, or would call themselves something else. The city represents EVERYBODY, and thus condoning or inviting a religious-specific prayer can make people of other faiths/beliefs feel unrepresented or in a position of inequality.

I think the commissioners on the board right now would not do that, but what if the LDS church wanted to pray to Joseph Smith, or a Wiccan coven leader asked to pray for the commission. You couldn't, I don't think, exclude them.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

"but what if the LDS church wanted to pray to Joseph Smith, or a Wiccan coven leader asked to pray for the commission. You couldn't, I don't think, exclude them."

But you know they would. Why not just do away with prayer altogether in the council meetings? Everyone knows that they are praying to the Christian God, so anyone who believes differently is left feeling left out at best, and offended at worst. Just do away with the prayer. Many towns don't even have one.

Anonymous said...

Just do away with the prayer. Many towns don't even have one.

Just another case where the present Generations are using Government to replace GOD!

How many times in history have we seen this repeated?

Guess what happened to most of those Societies/Governments and Countries!

"Politically Correct" = Socialism and Communism.

Anonymous said...

I think you need a new poll question!

What do you think the world and USA would be like with a lot less LAWYERS?

A. Better

B. Worse

C. I am a Lawyer (I have no
opinion just a
job!)

Anonymous said...

It looks like a couple of christians have been very busy voting multiple times in your online poll. Ironic that the ones wanting more god in their government would deceive people like that isn't it!?

Anonymous said...

Ironic that the ones wanting more god in their government would deceive people like that isn't it!?

More God in their Government?

How about less Government then their won't be as much God in it!